Skip to content
Alphamark Venture Partners
Blog

What Your Startup's Valuation Report Actually Says: DCF, Rule 11UA and the Three Different Reports Indian Law Asks For, Decoded

By the Alphamark Venture Partners teamPublished 21 September 2026Updated 15 October 20264 min read

Every priced round in India comes with a valuation report that says your shares are worth at least what the investor is paying. Founders rarely read it. What it is for, which law asks for which report, and why it does not set your price.

The short answer

A valuation report in an Indian startup round does not decide your price; the negotiation does. The report exists to show regulators that the price is at or above fair value. Depending on who invests, you may need a registered valuer's report under the Companies Act, a FEMA fair value certificate for non-resident investors, and, for tax purposes, a valuation under Rule 11UA: a merchant banker's fair market value for ESOP exercises, and a prescribed book-value formula for secondary transfers of equity shares. Most are built on discounted cash flow projections that are designed to support the agreed price.

Who this is for: Founders about to close a priced round who need to commission or sign off a valuation report, and founders confused by how a ₹40 Cr valuation "becomes" official.

Summary: what most founders miss

  • Your price comes from the term sheet. The valuation report confirms that the price meets legal floors, not the other way round.
  • Three different laws can ask for a valuation: the Companies Act, FEMA and the Income-tax rules. One valuer can often cover all, if briefed.
  • The DCF and the five extra methods Rule 11UA allowed for non-residents were built for angel tax, which no longer applies to share issues. Today the tax rules mainly matter for ESOPs and for secondary transfers, where equity shares use a book-value formula, not DCF.
  • No single rule fixes how old a report can be, but investors' counsel and the bank filing your FC-GPR expect one dated close to allotment, usually within 60 to 90 days. Stale reports are a common diligence finding.
  • A DCF that justifies ₹60 Cr today becomes evidence against you if you later sell shares at ₹40 Cr. Keep projections defensible.

In every Indian priced round, someone eventually asks: "Who is doing the valuation report?" Founders often assume the report decides the valuation. It does not. It is paperwork that confirms, for three different sets of rules, that the price you negotiated is not below fair value.

Understanding what it is and is not saves time, money and awkward questions later.

Why does a startup need a valuation report at all?

The three reports and what they are for
LawWhen it appliesWho can signWhat it confirms
Companies Act (preferential allotment)Any issue of shares or convertibles to specific investorsIBBI-registered valuerThe price is justified for a preferential allotment
FEMA (foreign investment)Any issue to a non-resident investorChartered accountant, SEBI-registered merchant banker or practising cost accountantThe price is not below fair value under an internationally accepted method
Income-tax (Rule 11UA)ESOP perquisite value; secondary transfers of sharesSEBI-registered merchant banker for ESOP fair market value; for secondary transfers of equity shares, a prescribed book-value formula, no report neededFair market value for tax purposes

Swipe the table sideways to see all columns.

Since angel tax was abolished for shares issued from FY 2024-25, the income-tax valuation matters for ESOPs and secondary transfers, not for primary share issues. For secondary transfers of equity shares, Rule 11UA(1)(c)(b) uses an adjusted book-value formula; preference shares such as CCPS use an open-market price.

Which methods do valuers use?

Valuation methods Rule 11UA allowed for share issues (2023 amendment, built for angel tax)
MethodAvailable forWhat it doesStartup reality
Net asset value (NAV)Residents and non-residentsBook value of assets minus liabilitiesUsually far below round price for a startup
Discounted cash flow (DCF)Residents and non-residentsPresent value of projected future cash flowsThe default for startup rounds
Comparable company multipleNon-residentsApplies peer valuation multiplesUseful when listed peers exist
Probability weighted expected returnNon-residentsWeights several exit scenariosUsed for complex cap tables
Option pricing methodNon-residentsValues classes of shares with different rightsRelevant for CCPS with preferences
Milestone analysisNon-residentsValues based on milestones achievedEarly-stage and deep tech
Replacement costNon-residentsCost to rebuild the businessRarely used for consumer

Swipe the table sideways to see all columns.

How the DCF is actually built

In practice, the valuer receives your agreed price and your business plan, then builds a DCF using your projections, a discount rate and a terminal value. The projections usually come from the same model you showed investors.

What drives a startup DCF
InputTypical rangeEffect on value
Revenue growth in projection yearsYour plan, often 50% to 100% a year early onThe biggest lever
Terminal growth rate4% to 6%Small changes move value a lot
Discount rate20% to 30% for early-stage startupsHigher rate, lower value
Terminal year marginEBITDA margin at maturityLarge effect
Projection period5 to 10 yearsLonger periods usually raise value

Common mistakes founders make

  1. Commissioning the report too early. Investors' counsel and the bank filing your FEMA return want a report dated close to allotment, usually within 60 to 90 days. A report from four months before closing will usually need redoing.
  2. One report for the wrong purpose. A Companies Act report may not satisfy FEMA for foreign investors unless the valuer addresses both.
  3. No ESOP valuation. When employees exercise options, you need a fair market value on the exercise date for tax deduction. See The ESOP Top-Up Trap.
  • Assuming a secondary below the round price is a tax problem. For equity shares, the tax floor on a secondary sale is an adjusted book-value formula, which for most loss-making startups is far below the round price, so a discounted secondary is usually safe. Profitable or asset-heavy companies, and CCPS, are different. Compute the number before you agree the price. See Angel Tax Is Gone.
  1. Mixing up price per share and valuation. The report values per share, on a stated share count. If your ESOP pool or conversions change the count, the numbers must match the SSA.

Case study

The report that did not match the round

Personal care brand, ₹12 Cr seed round, lead investor a US fund investing directly

Situation

The company secretary commissioned a registered valuer's report under the Companies Act in March. The round closed in July.

What was missed

The report was too old for the investor's counsel and the bank filing the FC-GPR, did not address FEMA for the US investor, and valued shares on a pre-ESOP share count, while the SSA included a new pool.

What changed

A firm that was both a registered valuer and a SEBI merchant banker issued a fresh report covering the Companies Act, FEMA and Rule 11UA, on the post-pool fully diluted share count, dated two weeks before allotment.

Outcome

The allotment went through with a clean FC-GPR filing. The first report's fee was wasted, and closing slipped by three weeks.

The lesson

Brief the valuer on every purpose, every investor type and the final share count, and time the report for the closing date.

Illustrative case. Figures are representative of patterns in Indian rounds, not a specific company.

Related: How Investors Really Value Consumer Brands. About to close a round? Talk to us about the closing checklist.

Sources

Read next: CCPS vs CCD vs convertible notes and the pre-Series A playbook. Preparing to raise? See how our pre-Series A fundraising support works.

Questions founders ask us

Does a valuation report decide my startup's valuation?

No. The investor and founder agree the price. The report confirms it is at or above fair value under the relevant law.

Who can issue a valuation report for a startup fundraise in India?

An IBBI-registered valuer for Companies Act purposes; a chartered accountant, SEBI-registered merchant banker or practising cost accountant for FEMA; and, for ESOP fair market value under the tax rules, a SEBI-registered merchant banker. Secondary transfers of equity shares use a prescribed book-value formula.

What valuation method is used for startups in India?

Mostly discounted cash flow. For non-resident investors, Rule 11UA also allows comparable company multiples, probability weighted expected return, option pricing, milestone analysis and replacement cost.

How old can a valuation report be?

No single rule sets one validity period. The old 90-day window applied to angel tax valuations, which no longer apply to share issues. In practice, investors' counsel and banks expect a report dated within about 60 to 90 days of allotment.

Do I need a valuation report now that angel tax is gone?

Yes. Company law still requires a valuation for preferential allotments, FEMA requires fair value for non-resident investors, and ESOP and secondary transactions need tax valuations.

About the author

Written by the Alphamark Venture Partners team, a fundraising advisory firm helping founders raise seed, angel and pre-Series A rounds, with a focus on consumer, consumer tech and consumer AI. Rules, figures and benchmarks are checked against the sources listed and are current as of the date shown. This is general information, not legal, tax or investment advice.

Raising in the next 6 months?

We typically work with brands doing ₹30L+ in monthly revenue raising ₹1 Cr to ₹15 Cr. Share your deck and numbers.

How our pre-series a rounds support works
Submit your startup

Keep reading

All guides